Chemoenzymatic Kinetic resolution of (R)-malathion in aqueous media
© Enríquez-Núñez et al. 2015
Received: 3 January 2015
Accepted: 10 July 2015
Published: 9 September 2015
Malathion (R,S)-diethyl-2-[(dimethoxyphosphorothioyl)sulfanyl]butanedioate is a chiral organophosphorus compound used widely as pesticide for suppression of harmful insects such as mosquitoes. It is well known that in biological systems (R)-malathion is the active enantiomer, therefore a sustainable approach could be the use of only the biologically active enantiomer. The resolution of the commercial racemic mixture to obtain the pure active enantiomer combined with a recycling of the undesired enantiomer through a racemization process could be an attractive alternative to reduce the environmental impact of this pesticide. Thus, this work evaluates the use of four commercially available lipases for enantioselective hydrolysis and separation of malathion enantiomers from the commercial racemic mixture.
Several lipases were methodologically assessed, considering parameters such as enzyme concentration, temperature and reaction rates. Among them, Candida rugosa lipase exhibited the best performance, in terms of enantioselectivity, E = 185 (selective to the (S)-enantiomer). In this way, the desired unreacted (R)-enantiomer was recovered in a 49.42 % yield with an enantiomeric excess of 87 %. The monohydrolized (S)-enantiomer was recovered and racemized in basic media, followed by esterification to obtain the racemic malathion, which was recycled. In this way, an enantioenriched mixture of (R)-malathion was obtained with a conversion of 65.80 % considering the recycled (S)-enantiomer.
This work demonstrated the feasibility of exploiting Candida rugosa lipase to kinetically resolve racemic malathion through an environmentally friendly recycling of the undesired (S)-enantiomer.
KeywordsEnantiomer Enzymatic Resolution Malathion
The importance of molecular chirality has been widely recognized in life sciences due to the different activity of stereoisomers in biological systems. Chiral enantiomers have the same chemical and physical properties in achiral environments, but they are often markedly different in terms of their biological activity such as, toxicity and environmental fate in chiral environments [1–3]. Organophosphorus pesticides (OP) are among the most important chemicals used for protection against agricultural and household pests. It is estimated that OP are worth nearly 40 % of the global market and they are expected to prevail in the near future. Chiral pesticides currently account for about 33 % of the worldwide commercially available pesticides, including some chiral OP. Among these, malathion (R,S)-[diethyl 2-[(dimethoxyphosphorothioyl)sulfanyl]butanedioate] is one of the chiral OP extensively used for insect and pests control on grains, fruits, nuts, cotton, and tobacco; which indeed is commercialized as a racemic mixture: (R,S)-malathion . It has been demonstrated that (R)-malathion is the target-active enantiomer of this particular racemic mixture. As a matter of fact, the (R)-enantiomer is 65x more toxic than the (S)-enantiomer [5, 6]. Therefore, the use of a single enantiomer could result in a reduction of the amount applied to treat pests minimizing the environmental impact and the cost of use. As the physical and chemical properties of enantiomers are the same, the preparation of pure enantiomers is still a challenge, especially in industrial processes. Generally, the industrial synthesis of chiral compounds generates the final products as racemic mixtures, which are difficult to separate. As an alternative to obtain pure enantiomers from racemic mixtures, the uses of enzymes is an attractive option.
Numerous biological processes are regulated by enzymes. In the last two decades, exploitation of enzymes in synthetic organic chemistry increased significantly due to its potential to catalyze reactions of specific substrates with high enantioselectivity and stereospecificity . Lipases are biocatalysts extracted in low yields from animals and plants. They can also be obtained in higher yields by gene expression in an appropriate natural or recombinant microorganism. Lipases are the most used enzymes in synthetic organic chemistry It has been demonstrated that they possess a great versatility in catalysis of different reactions such as hydrolysis, esterification, transesterification and aminolysis [8–11].
Several lipases have been used for the enantiomeric resolution of alpha substituted carboxylic acids as ibuprofen, naproxen, ketoprofen, flurbiprofen, suprofen and other alpha and beta substituted carboxylic acids [12–14]. Recently, we reported an enantioselective hydrolysis of (S)-ibuprofen alkyl esters in aqueous media, also an enantioselective esterification in aqueous media with different alcohol moieties using lipases as biocatalysts [14, 15].
The equilibrium between hydrolysis and synthesis depends highly on the water content in the reaction medium. Hydrolysis and ester synthesis are promoted by macro and micro aqueous solvent systems, respectively . The aim of this work was to find the best lipase-type enzyme for enantioselective hydrolysis of (R,S)-malathion in aqueous media, in order to obtain the unreacted (R)-enantiomer and the monohydrolized (S)-enantiomer. These two were separated from each other and the latter was subsequently racemized in basic media and then esterified to recover a racemic mixture, which was indeed recycled, thus improving the efficiency of the overall process. The exploitation of pure or enriched (R)-enantiomer could improve the efficiency of this pesticide by minimizing its dose and ultimately its environmental impact.
Results and discussion
The hydrolytic activity of the four lipases was determined by a modified methodology previously developed . Sunflower oil was used as enzymatic substrate, where Candida rugosa lipase showed the highest activity (31.8 U g−1 of biocatalyst), followed by porcine pancreatic lipase (13.3 U g−1 of biocatalyst), Mucor javanicus lipase (5.6 U g−1 of biocatalyst) and Candida antarctica lipase type B “Novozym 435” (3.6 U g−1 of biocatalyst). It is important to emphasize that the worst biocatalyst for this reaction was Candida antarctica lipase type B “Novozym 435”; despite being reported as a good biocatalyst for esterification and transesterification reactions. However, in this context many aspects might influence its biocatalyst activity. Perhaps, different enzyme sources (microorganism and mammalian vital organ) should naturally be expected to exhibit structural differences, which influence strongly on biocatalysts properties and activities, even in similar solvents . In addition, the nature of the support and its polarity can also affect the enzyme conformation, as well as the partition of substrates and products from the enzyme environment, which might prevent the access of the substrate to the enzyme active site. On this research, Candida antarctica lipase type B immobilized in a macroporous acrylic resin was unable to catalyze the hydrolysis of sunflower oil and malathion, which is likely due to the relative hydrophobic surface of the resin that difficult the interaction between the enzyme active site and the substrate when the reaction occurs in an aqueous solvent .
Lipase-catalyzed enantioselective hydrolysis of racemic malathion
Lipase-catalyzed enantioselective hydrolysis of racemic malathion at optimal conditions
Enzyme % - Temp °C
Candida rugosa lipase
Mucor javanicus lipase
Porcine pancreatic lipase
Our temperature effect studies aided to establish that temperatures above 40 °C leads to higher conversion yields with a lower enantioselectivity. The optimal temperature for the kinetic resolution of racemic malathion was determined to be 40 °C with all lipases. Although several studies of lipase kinetics have been carried out , the most common procedure is the use of the pseudo-first order model . Due to the absence of the correspondent UV signal in the chiral HPLC chromatograms of the (R)-malathion monocarboxylic acid, it can be assumed that only (S)-malathion was hydrolyzed by lipases. Under this hypothesis, using reaction data obtained from the experiments, different kinetics were tested for the hydrolysis reactions of (R,S)-malathion under the optimal conditions (40 °C, barometric pressure and 250 rpm of agitation) with the 3 active enzymes and all reactions fitted to the pseudo first-order kinetics .
Separation of enzymatic reaction products
Racemization of (S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid
Esterification of (R,S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid
Too ensure the reproducibility and accuracy of the data each experiment was conducted in triplicate. Results reported are the average values of the experiments.
Racemic malathion (R,S)-diethyl 2-[(dimethoxyphosphorothioyl)sulfanyl] butanedioate was isolated from inexpensive consumer pesticide “Malathion 1000®” donated by Velsimex S.A. de C.V. Candida rugosa lipase, Candida antarctica lipase type B, Lipase from Porcine pancreas and Mucor javanicus lipase were obtained from Sigma Aldrich Company. HPLC grade hexanes, isopropanol, sodium phosphate monobasic and dibasic were purchased from MAESA Chemicals. Cyclohexane, ethyl acetate and ethanol were purchased from FERMONT Company. All other analytical grade reagents and solvents were obtained from commercially sources.
High performance liquid chromatography (chiral) analysis
In order to monitor the development of the enantioselective enzymatic hydrolysis, the product separation and the acid catalyzed esterification reaction, high performance liquid chromatography was performed with chirlacel OJ chiral column (Diacel Chemical Industries). The HPLC instrument was equipped with a Dionex LPG-3400-D Quaternary Analytical Pump, Dionex UltiMate 3000 Diode Array Detector, Dionex solvent degaser and Chromeleon CM-PCS-1 Software. The mobile phase normally used was hexanes/isopropanol/trifluoroacetic acid (95:4.9,0.1 % v/v/v). The UV detector wavelength was set to 254 nm, the flow rate was 1.0 mL/min and the temperatures of the column and injection compartments were 15 °C. The chromatographic signal peaks of racemic malathion were confirmed by comparing their retention times (11.332 min (R)-malathion, 12.984 min for (S)-malathion and 7.897 min (S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid) and UV spectra with the obtained with the reference standard. The optical rotation was measured using an Atago® POLAX 2 L semiautomatic Polarimeter at 22 °C with a sodium lamp at 589 nm using samples with concentrations of 1 g/100 mL in anhydrous ethanol. Typically, about a gram of the mixture was separated and analyzed per run. A BÜCHI® rotary evaporator (Model R-210) was used to remove volatile solvents under reduced pressure. A Perkin Elmer Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrometer Model IRGX with Attenuated Total Reflection sampler was used for the characterization.
Isolation of (R,S)-malathion from commercially available pesticide formulation
Using 200 mL of cyclohexane as mobile phase in a 2.5 × 15 cm flash chromatography column packed with 5 μm silica gel as stationary phase, racemic malathion was isolated from a commercially available malathion pesticide formulation. The mobile phase with the extracted racemic malathion was evaporated at reduced pressure to isolate the racemic malathion. The isolated material was analyzed by chiral HPLC, H1 NMR and FTIR.
Lipase catalyzed enantioselective hydrolysis of malathion
In a typical reaction, 3.30 g (10 mmol) of racemic malathion, 40 mL of 0.1 M sodium phosphate buffer pH 7.02, 0.165–0.66 g of lipase and 0.5 g of Celite 577 fine for dispersion of lipase particles were added in to a 100 mL dry baffled-flat-bottom flask. The reactions were stirred at 300 rpm and 40 °C. The mixture was analyzed by chiral HPLC before adding lipase. By taking 1 mL samples and using extraction with hexanes, the reactions were monitored for at least 48 h by chiral HPLC and then stopped and centrifuged at 4500 rpm for 6 min for the enzyme recovery by decanting the reaction solution. The remaining oil was weighed and saved for further separation and analysis.
Enantioselectivity value (E-value) measurements
Isolation of (R)-malathion and racemization of (S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid
In order to isolate the desired product (R)-malathion and to avoid its racemization, a weak base was used to produce the (S)-malathion sodium monocarboxylate. About 40 mL of the decanted reaction solution was extracted three times with 40 mL of 5 % v/w NaHCO3 aqueous solution. The desired (R)-malathion was isolated by removing the solvent by evaporation at reduced pressure.
Racemization of (S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid
In a 100 mL round bottom flask the undesired subproduct (S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid 1.51 g (5 mmol) was mixed with 40 mL of aqueous Ca2CO3 at different concentrations 5, 10, 15, 20, 25 and 30 % w/w. Then the mixture was stirred for 60 min. In order to monitor the racemization reactions, 1 mL of sample was removed from the reaction solution to slowly be acidified with 3 % HCl w/v to induce the formation of the corresponding malathion monocarboxylic acid. Once the racemization was achieved, the solution was acidified and the racemic mixture was extracted by triplicated with hexanes and evaporated at reduced pressure to be analyzed by chiral HPLC determining the residual weight and enantiomeric excess.
Esterification of (R,S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid
Typically in a 100 mL baffled-flat-bottom flask 1.51 g (5 mmol) of (R,S)-malathion monocarboxylic acid, 5 mL of ethanol and 30 mL of solvent (anhydrous ethanol, acetone, dioxane and acetonitrile) and 1 mL of concentrated sulfuric acid were added. The mixture was refluxed and stirred for 8 h using a Dean Stark apparatus and molecular sieves to remove water, the undesired byproduct. The reaction mixture was extracted by triplicated with 30 mL of cyclohexane. The combined organic layers were dried with magnesium sulfate and evaporated at reduced pressure to give (R,S)-malathion. The compound matched perfectly with the physical characteristics of malathion, an oily compound with garlic odor and yellow color. The isolated malathion was analyzed by Chiral HPLC and the optical rotation matching satisfactorily with the standard of reference.
Comparison of commercially available lipases as biocatalysts for the enantioselective hydrolysis of (R,S)-malathion was performed. the obtained results suggested that Candida rugosa lipase was the best biocatalyst of the lipases studied, showing conversion yields up to 49.47 %, with acceptable enantioselectivity of E = 185 to the S enantiomer. It was found that temperature of 40 °C and a weight ratio of 0.15:10 for substrate:enzyme were optimal for all reactions. The monohydrolyzed (S)-malathion, was successfully racemized and esterified obtaining, (R,S)-malathion for further recycling. In conclusion, this work demonstrated the feasibility of exploiting Candida rugosa lipase to kinetically resolve racemic malathion through an environmentally friendly recovery of the undesired (S)-enantiomer. This methodology could also be applied for the resolution of other OP’s such as Phentoate, which also contains a chiral group and it is indeed a pesticide widely used worldwide.
We gratefully acknowledge the financial support of the Mexican Department of Education (F-PROMEP-38/Rev-03 SEP-23-005), the Department of Chemistry of the Autonomous University of Chihuahua and VELSIMEX SA de CV.
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
- Potec I, Cieslak L, Sledzinski B, Ksycinska H. Simple synthesis of malathion and malaoxon enantiomers, and isomalathion diasteromers: toxicity-configuration relationship. Pest Sci. 1998;53:165–71.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Liu W, Ye J, Jin M. Enantioselectivephytoeffects of chiral pesticides. J Agric Food Chem. 2009;57:2087–95.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kimihiko Y, Yasuhide T, Katakawa J, Ueno H, Nakamuro K. Kinetic analysis for hydrolysis of malathion by carboxylesterases in wheat kernels. J Health Sci. 2007;5:507–13.Google Scholar
- Berkman CE, Thompson CM. Synthesis of chiral malathion and isomalathion. Tetrahedron Lett. 1992;33:1415–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Li L, Zhou S, Jin L, Zhang Z, Liu W. Enantiomeric separation of organophosphorus pesticides by high-performance liquid chromatography, gas chromatography and capillary electrophoresis and their applications to environmental fate and toxicity assays. J Chromatogr B Analyt Technol Biomed Life Sci. 2010;878(17-18):1264–76.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Mingjing S, Donghui L, Ziheng D, Ranhong L, Zhiqiang Z, Peng W. Enantioselective behavior of malathion enantiomers in toxicity to beneficial organisms and their dissipation in vegetables and crops. J Hazard Mater. 2012;237–238:140–6.Google Scholar
- Zaks A, Klibanov AM. Enzyme-catalyzed processes in organic solvents. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 1985;82:3192–6.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Aarthy M, Saravanan P, Gowthaman MK, Rose C, Kamini NR. Enzymatic transesterification for production of biodiesel using yeast lipases: An overview. chemical engineering research and design. Chem Eng Res Des. 2014;92:1591–601.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Peiliang X, Suoqin Z, Huayu M, Aijun Z, Xiaoli L, Liangyu Z. Stereoselective synthesis of caffeic acid amides via enzyme-catalyzed asymmetric aminolysis reaction. J Biotechnol. 2013;168:552–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Panagiota-Yiolanda S, Athanasios F, Michalis F, Maria K, Maria P, Leonidas GT, et al. Advances in lipase-catalyzed esterification reactions. Biotechnol Adv. 2013;31:1846–59.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yuan-Yuan Z, Jun-Hong L. Kinetic study of enantioselective hydrolysis of (R, S)-ketoprofen ethyl ester using immobilized T. laibacchii lipase. Biochem Eng J. 2011;54:40–6.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Jyun-Fen C, Pei-Yun W, An-Chi W, Shau-Wei T. Lipase-catalyzed alcoholytic resolution of (R, S)-flurbiprofenyl azolides for preparation of (R)-NO-flurbiprofen ester prodrugs. Process Biochem. 2011;46:960–5.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Tsai SW, Huang CM. Enantioselective synthesis of (S)-suprofen ester prodrugs by lipase in cyclohexane. Enzyme Microb Technol. 1999;25:682–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chavez-Flores D, Salvador JM. Commercially viable resolution of ibuprofen. Biotechnol J. 2009;4:1222–4.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chavez-Flores D, Salvador JM. Facile conversion of racemic ibuprofen to (S)-ibuprofen. Tetrahedron: Asymmetry. 2012;23:237–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Anthonsen T, Helge-Hoff B. Resolution of derivatives of 1,2-propanediol with lipase B from Candida antarctica. Effect of substrate structure, medium, water activity and acyl donor on enantiomeric ratio. Chem Phys Lipids. 1998;93:199–207.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Alves JS, Vieira NS, Cunha AS, Silva AM, Záchia-Ayub MA, Fernandez-Lafuente R, et al. Combi-lipase for heterogeneous substrates: a new approach for hydrolysis of soybean oil using mixtures of biocatalysts. RSC Adv. 2014;4:6863–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- De Paula AV, Nuñez GFM, Silva JDL, De Castro HF, Dos Santos JC. Screening of Food Grade Lipases to be Used in Esterification and Interesterification Reactions of Industrial Interest. Appl Biochem Biotechnol. 2010;160:1146–56.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chen B, Hu J, Miller EM, Xie W, Cai M, Gross RA. Candida antarctica Lipase B Chemically Immobilized on Epoxy-Activated Micro- and Nanobeads: Catalysts for Polyester Synthesis. Biomacromolecules. 2008;9:463–71.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yoshii K, Tonogai Y, Katakawa J, Ueno H, Nakamuro K. Kinetic Analysis for Hydrolysis of Malathion by Carboxylesterase in wheat Kernels. J Health Sci. 2007;53(5):507–13.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Yu-Chun X, Hui-Zhou L, Jia-Yong C. Candida rugosa lipase catalyzed esterification of racemic ibuprofen with butanol: racemization of R-ibuprofen. Biotechnol Lett. 1998;20:455–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Kulshrestha AS, Gao W, Gross RA. Glycerol Copolyesters: Control of Branching and Molecular Weight Using a Lipase Catalyst. Macromolecules. 2005;38:3193–204.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Fazlena A, Kamaruddin M, Zulkali M. Dynamic Kinetic Resolution: Alternative Approach in Optimizing (S)-Ibuprofen Production. Bioprocess Biosyst Eng. 2006;28:227–33.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Gargouri Y, Chahinian H, Moreau H, Ransac S, Verger R. Inactivation of Pancreatic and Gastric Lipase by THL and C12:0-TNB: a Kinetic Study with Emulsified Tributyrin. Biochim Biophys Acta. 1991;1085:322–8.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Arroyo R, Sanchez–Muniz FJ, Cuesta C, Burguillo FJ, Sanchez–Montero JM. Hydrolysis of used Frying Palm Olein and Sunflower Oil Catalyzed by Porcine Pancreatic Lipase. Lipids. 1996;31:1133–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Ducret A, Trani M, Lortie R. Lipase-Catalyzed Enantioselective Esterification of Ibuprofen in Organic Solvents under Controlled Water Activity. Enzyme Microb Technol. 1998;22:212–6.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hiroshi I, Ogata A, Nafie LA, Dukor RK. Structural determination of molecular stereochemistry using a VCD spectroscopy and a conformational code: absolute configuration and solution conformation of a chiral liquid pesticide, (R)-(+)-malathion. Chirality. 2009;21:172–80.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chen CS, Wu SH, Girdaukas G, Sih GC. Quantitative analyses of biochemical kinetic resolution of enantiomers. Enzyme-catalyzed esterifications in water-organic solvent biphasic systems. J Am Chem Soc. 1987;109:2812–7.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sun M, Liu D, Dang Z, Li R, Zhou Z, Wang P. Enantioselective behavior of malathion enantiomers in toxicity to beneficial organisms and their dissipation in vegetables and crops. J Hazard Mater. 2012;237–343:140–6.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Sun M, Liu D, Zhou G, Li J, Qiu X, Zhou G, et al. Enantioselective degradation and chiral stability of malathion in environmental samples. J Agric Food Chem. 2012;60(1):372–9.View ArticleGoogle Scholar